Legal Feeds
Canadian Lawyer

Editorial: Close community

The Ontario legal community is incredibly inter-connected.

Editorial: Close community
Editorial Obiter: Gabrielle Giroday
This is a great thing. When I walked into an Ontario Bar Association event in Toronto this past week, I met leaders in many practice areas sharing insight about their work. It was inspiring.

But there’s a downside to being in a close community or village.

Law Times reports in this issue that a judge has stopped the Kenora Crown attorney’s office from prosecuting a case of a man accused of charges including assault with a weapon, aggravated assault and sexual assault, after his defence lawyer took a job as a Crown days before his trial was set to begin.

“In the instant case, choice of counsel is not a consideration. The balancing of the integrity of the justice system and the mobility of lawyers is done in a context where the liberty of the accused is at stake,” said Ontario Superior Court Justice Douglas Shaw in his decision barring the Kenora Crowns from prosecuting R. v. Mandamin.  Shaw ordered a Crown from another area be brought in to prosecute the man.

In our last issue, Law Times reported that in Ontario v. Chartis Insurance Company of Canada, the Ontario Court of Appeal upheld a decision barring a Toronto firm from representing an insurance company in a coverage dispute because of a potential conflict of interest, even though the firm had followed all ethical guidelines, including making sure a lawyer had a work space several offices away from his colleagues.  

In both cases, there was no suggestion of wrongdoing by lawyers involved. Rather, concerns centred on whether the public might perceive that confidential information could be inadvertently disclosed. While it may be frustrating for firms, judges are right to take a cautious approach. There is too much at stake when it comes to reputational harm.

Add comment

  • Access to Justice
    Access to Justice The Action Group on Access to Justice (TAG) strives to inform the public on the importance of the people having access to legal resources and…
  • Legal Aid lawyers rally for collective bargaining rights
    Legal Aid lawyers rally for collective bargaining rights Legal Aid Ontario lawyers held three protests in July to push the provincial government to support their attempts to unionize. The lawyers have been in…
  • Jane-Finch community gets employment law help
    Jane-Finch community gets employment law help Osgoode Hall Law School's Community Legal Aid Services Programme recently opened an employment law division for Toronto's Jane-Finch community.Phanath Im, review counsel for the division,…
More Law Times TV...

Law Times poll

In a recent report, Justice Michael Tulloch said there is ‘no reason’ why the director of the province’s Special Investigations Unit needs to be a lawyer. Do you agree with Tulloch?
Yes, there is no reason why the head of the SIU needs to be a lawyer, especially given that this is not a requirement in other places.
No, the role requires a specialized knowledge of criminal investigations, and the professional expertise a lawyer brings.