While he is known by colleagues as a “lawyer’s lawyer,” Chris Paliare says he would never describe himself that way.
The Toronto lawyer and partner at Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein LLP was given the Ontario Bar Association’s 2016 Award for Excellence in Civil Litigation at a dinner in his honour in early November.
Paliare, who represents lawyers in disciplinary matters, says he is flattered by the “lawyer’s lawyer” label, but he honestly does not really know what it means.
“I guess I’m someone who people trust and whose judgment they appreciate,” he says. Paliare was called to the bar in 1973 and completed his articling at Cameron Brewin and Scott.
He credits his success to the luck of having been surrounded by lawyers at the firm such as former attorney general Ian Scott and former Court of Appeal justice Stephen Goudge while at the firm.
“I was really lucky as an articling student and a young lawyer to have attached my caboose to that train,” he says.
He later became a founding partner of litigation boutique Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein in 2001.
Paliare, who is considered a pioneer in boutique litigation, has appeared before every level of trial and appellate court in Ontario, right up to the Supreme Court of Canada.
TRUDEAU CHOOSES LAWYERS FOR SENATE
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has appointed two Ontario lawyers to serve in the Senate.
Kim Pate and Howard Wetston will join the ranks of the red chamber as “independent senators.”
Pate is a human rights expert and a part-time law professor at the University of Ottawa, who has served as the executive director of the Canadian Association of Elizabeth Fry Societies since 1992.
She has worked to help incarcerated women reintegrate into society when they are released.
Wetston is counsel with Goodmans LLP, an adjunct law professor at the University of Toronto and a former trial judge at the Federal Court of Canada.
LAO LAWYERS VOTE TO UNIONIZE
After three years of pushing for unionization, Legal Aid Ontario staff lawyers have voted to join the Society of Energy Professionals.
In a 246-76 vote, lawyers approved the move to have the union represent them in bargaining with LAO.
The lawyers first requested to unionize in 2013, but they were rejected by their employer.
LAO resisted the request until August, when they agreed to negotiate with the Society.
LAO’s articling students have also started their own push to be represented by the union.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times recently reported that a Law Society of Upper Canada committee has reversed its position to end the Law Practice Program.
Readers were asked if they agree with this decision.
More than 69 per cent said yes, the decision to endorse extending the pilot program for an additional two years is a wise move.
Almost 31 per cent said no, the decision does not reflect the committee’s original report.
An Aboriginal Legal Services lawyer spoke to a United Nations committee fighting discrimination against women for the first time in the group’s history.
Emily Hill, an ALS senior staff lawyer, attended a meeting of the Committee for the Elimination of the Discrimination Against Women in Geneva, Switzerland on Oct. 25 to share the barriers to equality faced by aboriginal women in Canada.
“The questions raised by CEDAW are front and centre in the work we do with victims,” Hill said.
“We assist women who have experienced violence and face discrimination when they seek help from the police and the courts.”
CEDAW is composed of 23 independent experts who monitor the implementation of the committee’s convention, which requires states to take “all appropriate measures, including legislation, to ensure the full development and advancement of women, for the purpose of guaranteeing them the exercise and enjoyment of human rights and fundamental freedoms.”
Christa Big Canoe, ALS’ legal director, says the organization also wanted to voice concerns it had with a report submitted by the federal government to CEDAW. Big Canoe says the tone of the report concerning the launch of the inquiry into missing and murdered indigenous women was not appropriate.
SURVEY SAYS UPTICK IN CLASS ACTIONS
Canadian companies have not been as proactive as their global counterparts when it comes to adopting measures to mitigate the risk of litigation, according to a new survey by Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP.
The survey also found that Canadian companies faced more than double the amount of class action lawsuits in the last 12 months than the previous year. Contract and labour disputes also remain some of the more numerous types of litigation Canadian companies face, the survey said.
LSUC SUSPENDS LAWYER
The Law Society of Upper Canada has suspended a Toronto lawyer after a tribunal found he had a sexual relationship with a client.
The tribunal suspended Antonio Macri for two and a half months after finding he had failed to tell his firm about the relationship, which was with a client he was representing in a family law matter. The tribunal also found Macri sent “a series of uncivil text messages and e-mails” to the client, implying he would use confidential information against her if she failed to reimburse him funds he lent her. Macri’s licence was suspended starting Oct. 28. He was also fined $2,500.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times reported that the federal government has introduced a bill to modernize the Canada Business Corporations Act, but lawyers say it could sow confusion for companies that are listed under the TSX and were incorporated under the act.
Readers were asked if they agreed with the steps to modernize the act.
More than 33 per cent said yes, modernizing the act is a good idea that will have positive outcomes for companies.
Almost 67 per cent said no, the changes the bill proposes will create confusion for companies and not achieve their intended results.
Despite the dismissal of an injunction to stop the Cleveland Indians baseball team from using its name and logo during playoff games at the Rogers Centre, lawyers say the fight is far from over.
Canadian indigenous activist Douglas Cardinal has filed human rights complaints with both the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario and the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal, in addition to his application for an interlocutory injunction with the Ontario Superior Court of Justice.
Cardinal, who is of Blackfoot descent, wants a ban on the use of the team’s logo, as well as the word Indian in association with that logo, which the case argues is racist and discriminatory under Canadian law.
“What we’re saying is when you deliver a service in Ontario, whether it be Rogers through the Rogers Centre or its broadcast, or the Cleveland team by coming and participating in that service, when you’re in this province you have to deliver that service without discrimination,” says Rebecca Jones, partner at Lenczner Slaght Royce Smith Griffin LLP and counsel for Cardinal. Justice Thomas McEwen has yet to give reasons for his ruling.
Another of the lawyers representing Cardinal, Paul-Erik Veel also of Lenczner, says he was disappointed with the decision, but he adds that the rejection of the injunction does not necessarily touch upon whether the name and logo are discriminatory.
“The question of whether an injunction is appropriate involves a lot of considerations beyond the merits of the case and one of the things our opponents argued quite strenuously was all of the practical problems that could emerge if an injunction was granted,” he says.
LSUC TEMPORARILY SUSPENDS LAWYER
The Law Society of Upper Canada has temporarily suspended the licence of a Toronto lawyer accused of sexual assault. Toronto police arrested Francois Lesieur in late September for allegedly sexually assaulting girls under the age of 18. In submissions to a tribunal, law society counsel argued there were reasonable grounds to believe there would be a significant risk of harm to members of the public “if an order is not made suspending the Responding Party’s license.”
SEGREGATION OVERUSED: OHRC
More than 38 per cent of prisoners placed in solitary confinement in Ontario’s prisons in late 2015 had been flagged for mental health problems, according to data released by the Ontario Human Rights Commission.
The OHRC released the data to step up the pressure on the provincial government to end solitary confinement in Ontario’s correctional facilities.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times reported that labour lawyers say Legal Aid Ontario is dragging its feet when it comes to allowing its articling students to unionize.
Readers were asked if they think LAO is right to push for seven bargaining units to represent the articling students.
Roughly 20 per cent said yes, LAO is right to participate in this dispute at the Ontario Labour Relations Board, even if this delays the process overall.
The remaining 80 per cent said no, LAO should stop stalling and the union is right to push for one province-wide arrangement in terms of representing the articling students.
SMALL TORONTO FIRM WINS PRO BONO HONOUR
The Bellissimo Law Group will be receiving the Law Firm Pro Bono Award from Pro Bono Ontario.
Since 2012, the firm of seven lawyers — the Bellissimo Law Group — has provided pro bono help to more than 100 families who have children at Toronto’s Hospital for Sick Children and are also dealing with immigration issues.
Alain Roussy wants to know if more can be done to protect language rights in the Rules of Professional Conduct.
The University of Ottawa law professor was one of two people recently awarded academic fellowships through the OBA Foundation this year. He plans to use the $15,000 he was granted to review the history and adequacy of language rights provisions in the rules.
Rules 3.2-2A and 3.2-2B say a lawyer shall, when appropriate, advise a client of their language rights, and that a lawyer cannot handle the matter of a client who wishes to retain a lawyer in their own language if they are unable to provide the service in the chosen language.
“My question is whether that is sufficient,” says Roussy.
“Are they specific enough and are they broad enough?”
The OBA Foundation annually awards two fellowships that concern legal ethics and professionalism studies.
Paul Michell, of Lax O’Sullivan Lisus Gottlieb LLP, was awarded the other $5,000 fellowship to look at what he calls the “ethical consequences of disaggregation in the legal practice.”
“A lot of the ethical rules that govern lawyers assume a sort of traditional law firm model, where a client hires a law firm and all of the legal work for that particular mandate is done by that firm internally,” he says.
“That’s not really the way at least some kinds of legal work are increasingly being done.”
As in-house departments get bigger, an increasing number of commercial clients want to do some of the work and farm out only certain portions to specialist external lawyers, Michell says. Others will ask a firm to manage a transaction, but they will insist that certain parts be farmed out to contract lawyers who are considered specialists, he says.
“The conflict rules and ethical rules that have traditionally applied don’t necessarily map very well on to the new practice structures and business realities,” he says.
TORONTO LAWYER ELECTED SECRETARY GENERAL OF INTERNATIONAL BAR ASSOCIATION
The International Bar Association has elected a Miller Thomson LLP partner to serve as its next secretary general.
James Klotz, who is an international business lawyer, is only the third Canadian to be elected to the position at the IBA over the last 50 years.
“The IBA is the global thought leader of the profession of law, seeking to preserve and enhance the rule of law worldwide, and I am honoured to have been entrusted with the responsibility that comes with this position,” Klotz said in a press release.
Klotz, who specializes in anti-corruption and governance, has served on the IBA’s management board for five years.
LAO CALLS FOR LINDEN AWARD NOMINATIONS
Legal Aid Ontario is calling for nominations for the Sidney B. Linden Award.
The annual award is named after Justice Linden, who was the first chairman of LAO, and seeks to honour legal professionals who have shown a long commitment to helping low-income people.
Lawyers in the private sector, paralegals, academics, LAO employees, community legal clinic staff and people who work at a student legal aid services society are all eligible for the award.
For more information or nomination forms, visit www.legalaid.on.ca.
LAO is accepting nominations until Nov. 4 at 5 pm.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times recently reported that the Ontario Court of Appeal has ruled an illegal immigrant will not get provincial compensation after a vehicle accident.
Readers were asked if they agree with this decision.
Almost 62 per cent said yes, illegal immigrants to Canada should not receive compensation for injuries sustained in a vehicle accident in Ontario because it’s the law.
More than 38 per cent said no, illegal immigrants to Canada should receive provincial compensation for injuries sustained in vehicle accidents that happen within Ontario.
The Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund is intervening in a case that will challenge provisions in the Indian Act.
In Gehl v Attorney General of Canada, Lynn Gehl is challenging a policy that says an applicant for status under the act can be rejected if he or she does not have their father listed on their birth certificate, as he is assumed to be non-Indian.
Critics say this policy discriminates on the basis of sex and marital status.
“Indigenous women are disproportionately targeted for sexual violence and they are disproportionately single parents living in poverty,” said LEAF’s legal director, Kim Stanton.
“An Indigenous mother should not be forced to choose between ensuring her child’s status (and the ensuing benefits) and a heightened risk of physical harm or social conflicts.”
The federal government denied the request by Gehl, who is an Algonquin-Anishinaabe woman, to register for “Indian status” under the act in 1994 because her grandfather was not registered on her mother’s birth certificate. Status provides access to benefits such as tax exemptions.
LEGAL AID ONTARIO EXPANDS PILOT
Legal Aid Ontario is expanding a pilot project to fund proceedings at the Ontario Court of Justice where a second judicial pre-trial has been scheduled.
The pilot will run until March 31, 2018 at 15 locations across Ontario. Lawyers can submit requests to obtain coverage on the Legal Aid Ontario website.
For more information, contact LAO’s lawyer service centre at 1-866-979-9934.
LSUC RESPONDS TO CONSULTATIONS
The Law Society of Upper Canada wants laypersons to be involved in all stages of the judicial discipline process.
The idea was one of a number of recommendations the law society has made in response to consultations the federal government is holding about the justice system.
The law society’s recommendations also included that the federal government base its new judicial appointments process on Ontario’s, which is led by an independent committee. The LSUC also asked the government to commit to specific timelines in which judicial vacancies will be filled.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times recently reported that a new LSUC report on the barriers faced by racialized licensees recommends measures such as the LSUC doing an internal diversity assessment and providing equality and inclusion education to Convocation.
Readers were asked if they plan to read the report and support its recommendations.
About 67 per cent said yes, this report is a critical piece of insight on how to address the widespread barriers that racialized licensees face, and the recommendations can lead to important social change.
Another 33 per cent said no, they do not have plans to read the report and that this issue is very complex and needs more than the Law Society’s recommendations implemented to lead to meaningful social change.
DLA Piper (Canada) LLP and Dimock Stratton LLP have combined forces.
Starting Nov. 1, lawyers from the intellectual property firm will join DLA Piper’s Toronto office.
“It’s exciting, an exciting opportunity,” says Bruce Stratton, a partner at Dimock Stratton LLP, who will also be a partner in the new merger.
“The legal market is changing and becoming more of a global market, and for intellectual property, the global aspect is key and we see this as a way of connecting into an incredible global network,” Stratton added.
The Canadian arm of DLA Piper — which has six offices across the country — joined with DLA Piper, which spans more than 30 countries, in April last year.
Roger Meltzer, global co-chairman and co-chairman (Americas) of DLA Piper, hailed the merger with Stratton.
“This key market continues to generate a wealth of new opportunities, and with intellectual property and technology law standing at the core of so many major business transactions across sectors, this is an important step to boost our competitive edge and execute our growth strategy,” he said in a press release.
Dimock Stratton was founded in 1994 by Ron Dimock and Bruce Stratton.
The firm specializes in intellectual property litigation, as well as the acquisition, licensing and portfolio management of patents, trademarks and copyrights.
Dimock Stratton has 19 lawyers, 16 of which will be joining DLA Piper (Canada) LLP. Two partners and one associate are forming their own firm on Nov. 1, Stratton said.
OSGOODE HALL LAW PROFESSOR HONOURED AS 2016 TRUDEAU FELLOW
Poonam Puri has been named one of five Canadian academics who will receive research fellowships from the Pierre Elliott Trudeau Foundation this year.
The Osgoode Hall law professor will receive $225,000 over three years for a project called Piercing the Corporate Veil.
Through the project, Puri, who is an expert in corporate governance, is set to develop policy and legal solutions to deal with multinational corporations that have caused harm such as human rights or environmental abuses on communities.
ARI KAPLAN TO START NEW MEDIATION FIRM
Toronto lawyer Ari Kaplan is leaving Koskie Minsky LLP at the end of September to launch his own solo practice.
Kaplan, who became Canada’s first Qualified Mediator with recognized expertise in pension law in 2015, will focus his new firm — Mediation Benefits at Kaplan Law — on mediation in the pension and benefits sector.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times recently reported that a Law Society of Upper Canada committee has recommended ending the Law Practice Program after it finishes its pilot.
Readers were asked if they agree with this move.
More than 55 per cent said yes, the LPP should be scrapped because it has created a two-tier system. It’s time for it to go.
Almost 44 per cent said no, the LPP program should not be ended and is a much-needed alternative to articling.
As the daughter of Tanzanian immigrants who were not able to practise their chosen profession in Canada, Isfahan Merali always knew she wanted to practise in an area that would let her help communities that face barriers.
The human rights lawyer was recently appointed to serve on the Law Foundation of Ontario Board of Trustees, a post where Merali says she hopes to help the organization reach out to vulnerable communities.
Merali, who is tribunal counsel to the Consent and Capacity Board, says she also hopes to help share knowledge about access to justice and human rights.
Merali was elected as a bencher at the Law Society of Upper Canada in 2015.
$80,000 DONATION BY THOMSON ROGERS
Thomson Rogers is set to donate $80,000 to five different organizations that have helped its clients get back on their feet.
“You see these groups that do this work somewhat anonymously for the most part,” says Alan Farrer, the firm’s managing partner.
“Some of this work is unnoticed by a lot of people except those who are injured and need the help. So we thought we’d shine a bit of a light on it and give back a little, too.”
The firm is inviting the public to go on its web site, www.thomsonrogers.com, to watch videos of the stories from the five different nominees and vote. The amount of money each organization will receive will depend on where it places in the voting.
TORONTO LAWYER LOOKS TO MAKE A DIFFERENCE IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING
Bonnie Fish wants to put the issue of affordable housing on more people’s radar.
Over the last six years, the Toronto lawyer has been involved in the Kehilla Residential Programme — a rental assistance fund that helps those in need meet their housing costs.
“You get up in the morning, you go to work and then you go back home at night and feel secure in your dwelling.
If you’re not aware of those around that don’t have that same ability, you’re closing your eyes to the world around you,” says Fish, who is a partner at Fogler Rubinoff LLP.
Fish organizes an annual Kehilla event called Sukkahville, which is a design competition that challenges participants to build a sukkah — a temporary hut structure built during the Jewish festival of Sukkot.
There will also be a panel discussion about affordable housing at the event, which takes place Sept. 22 at the Design Exchange in downtown Toronto.
LAW TIMES POLL
The Law Times recently reported that a bill to stop genetic discrimination will be debated in the House of Commons.
Readers were asked if they think legislation to prevent genetic discrimination is needed.
Around 69 per cent said yes, legislation to prevent genetic discrimination is needed, as this is a serious and emerging problem.
The remaining 31 per cent said no, legislation is not needed, as the actual threat of genetic discrimination is negligible, and the solutions being proposed won’t be an efficient way to address the issue.
The South Asian Bar Association North American Foundation has tapped a Toronto lawyer to serve as one of its trustees.
Rustam “Rusty” Juma, legal counsel to Deloitte LLP, has been appointed to serve as a trustee for the foundation, which funds legal education and research programs that benefit the South Asian community.
Juma says initiatives he hopes to pursue as a trustee include mentorship programs for SABA members and scholarships for law students in need.
He also is looking to pursue advocacy initiatives carried out by legal clinics on behalf of South Asians.
“Rusty is a leader in our bar and our profession,” said Ranjan Agarwal, the president of SABA Toronto.
“He will be a valuable asset to the SABA North America Foundation in their public interest work across North America.”
Juma is a former vice president of SABA Toronto and also served on the local organization’s board for four years before stepping down in August.
CHARITY CHARTER CHALLENGE
McCarthy Tétrault LLP is representing an Ottawa charity on a Charter challenge to a section of the Income Tax Act.
Canada Without Poverty launched the challenge in the Ontario Superior Court, claiming s. 149.1 (6.2) of the act violates freedom of association. The charity says that under the section of the act, “initiatives taken to encourage interaction between people living in poverty with politicians and other decision-makers about strategies for the relief of poverty must be severely restricted.”
The charity has been under audit since the federal government started a program to scrutinize the supposed political activities of charities in 2012.
“CWP has found that the restrictions imposed by section 149.1 (6.2) are contrary to its charitable purpose and prevent it from pursuing the relief of poverty in a reasonable and effective manner,” the charity said in its notice of application.
The firm is taking on the case pro bono and declined to comment on the challenge.
MEDICO LEGAL SOCIETY DINNER
The Medico Legal Society of Toronto is set to host a dinner with speakers talking about medico-legal issues.
The event, which will take place the evening of Sept. 28, will include a talk on Bill 132, Ontario’s new sexual violence and harassment legislation, given by Lisa Hamilton, of Bell Temple LLP. The dinner costs $180.80 for members and $226 for non-members.
For more information, or to register, e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times recently reported that an Ottawa lawyer is arguing it should be easier to award costs against the Law Society of Upper Canada, in order to force the regulator to think harder about which cases it prosecutes.
Readers were asked if they agree with this position.
More than 79 per cent said yes, the bar should be lowered and the LSUC is overzealous in the cases it chooses to prosecute.
Almost 21 per cent said no, the regulator is doing its job correctly and costs should only be awarded in extreme circumstances.
The former Canadian ambassador to the United States and a past premier of Manitoba, Gary Doer, has joined Dentons in its Toronto office.
In the role of senior business adviser, Doer will be working with all of the firm’s offices across Canada (including Calgary, Edmonton, Ottawa, Montreal and Vancouver), throughout the United States and around the world.
“I think advocacy through an international law firm, particularly with assets in the United States, could be a real advantage for Canadians and for Americans to get stuff done,” says Doer.
Doer served as Canada’s ambassador to the United States from October 2009 to March 2016.
Prior to that, Doer was the 20th premier of Manitoba, from 1999 to 2009, leading the New Democratic Party to win three consecutive majority governments.
“I was involved as a premier in the European trade discussions and one of the big issues for Europe was procurement for subnational governments. I was very involved in that process and very aware of what the benefits are for Canada. I was very involved in the TPP (Trans Pacific Partnership) negotiations, which gives some certainty and parameters to state-owned enterprises in dealing with free market countries like Canada, the United States and Mexico,” says Doer.
He will work with Dentons’ Canada-U.S. trans-border practice.
Doer will also be deeply involved in the firm’s global public policy initiatives.
“We are honoured to welcome Gary to Dentons — his arrival further strengthens the unmatched talent and scope of our team of business and public policy advisors,” said Chris Pinnington, Dentons’ Canada chief executive officer, in a statement.
ATWOOD TO SPEAK AT LEAF EVENT
Noted Canadian writer Margaret Atwood will be the keynote speaker at the Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund’s Person’s Day Breakfast. The event will take place Oct. 19, from 7 a.m. to 9 a.m., at the Sheraton Centre in Toronto.
To learn more about the event, contact email@example.com or 416-595-7170. Tickets can be purchased online at www.leaf.ca/pdbtoronto2016/.
CABL EVENTS ON THE HORIZON
The Canadian Association of Black Lawyers will have its sixth annual conference Oct. 14, in partnership with the Law Society of Upper Canada. The conference will take place at the LSUC’s Donald Lamont Learning Centre, at 130 Queen Street West in Toronto. That evening at 6 p.m., there will be a 20th anniversary opening night reception, at the Fairmont Royal York’s Upper Canada Ballroom. On Oct. 15, CABL will have its 20th anniversary gala at the Fairmont Royal York’s Concert Hall Ballroom. More information and updates on these events are available at www.cabl.ca.
LAW TIMES POLL
A Law Times series has explored how technology is changing how lawyers operate. Readers were asked if they thought they would use a legal app in their practice in the next two years. About 56 per cent said yes, and that embracing new technologies helped them harness information in new ways.
About 44 per cent said no, while new technologies are important, some of the new tools proposed are not relevant to their work and not useful in their day-to-day practice.
For Frank Addario, some of his most memorable cases were the ones in which he was able to change the life of a client in trouble.
The Criminal Lawyers’ Association has given the veteran criminal lawyer a lifetime achievement award for his work as defence counsel over the years.
Called to the bar in 1985, Addario has defended clients at all levels of the courts right up to the Supreme Court of Canada.
Addario says some of the more rewarding cases he has worked on have been ones where he has been able to make a small difference in people’s lives.
He recalled the case of Brenda Batisse, an aboriginal woman he represented who had kidnapped a newborn baby from a hospital in 2007 after pretending to be pregnant to her partner.
Batisse suffered from mental health problems and Addario was able to get her sentence reduced on appeal.
“That was rewarding because that was someone whose life had been ruined and I was able to improve it just a tiny bit,” he says.
Addario was president of the CLA from 2006 to 2009, and he is credited with leading a successful effort in 2008 to get the government to inject more funding into Legal Aid Ontario.
“The program still needs support and improvement, but we took a giant step in 2008,” he says.
He will receive the 2016 G. Arthur Martin Criminal Justice Medal at a gala luncheon during the CLA annual convention in October.
RETIRING SCC JUSTICE CROMWELL MARKS LAURIER’S 175TH BIRTHDAY
Retiring Supreme Court Justice Thomas Cromwell is set to mark Sir Wilfrid Laurier’s 175th birthday with a special essay about Canada’s seventh prime minister.
Cromwell’s essay concerns Laurier’s 1864 valedictory address at McGill University’s law school.
“Here is the foundation of Laurier’s political beliefs,” Cromwell writes in the essay.
“He hoped that Canadian patriotism, mutual respect, compromise and adherence to the deep principle of justice would overcome linguistic, religious and regional divisions.”
Cromwell’s essay is part of a book, called Canada Always: The Defining Speeches of Sir Wilfrid Laurier, that examines some of Laurier’s more memorable oratory.
The book, which was edited by former journalist Arthur Milnes, is set to come out in October. Laurier’s birthday is Nov. 20.
VETERAN TAX LAWYER JOINS GOWLING WLG
Tax lawyer Steven Baum has joined Gowling WLG as a partner.
Baum has more than 25 years of experience advising banks, insurance companies and securities dealers on complex tax issues and will be working with the firm’s tax group to provide advice to clients across a broad range of sectors.
“Over the course of his career, Steven has built an impressive practice and proven himself a forward-thinking leader in the field of tax law,” said Peter Lukasiewicz, CEO of Gowling WLG (Canada) LLP.
“With his specialized expertise in the financial services sector and ability to foster strong relationships with financial institutions, Steven will be an important addition to our tax team and a significant resource for our clients.”
Baum has also been a taxation instructor at the Ontario Bar Admission Course and an adjunct professor at Osgoode Hall Law School.
LAW TIMES POLL
A Law Times column last week argued that people should not have to get undergraduate degrees before going to law school.
Readers were asked if they agree with this position.
Almost 23 per cent said yes, going to get an undergraduate education is a waste of time and delays a lawyer’s entry into the workforce.
Roughly 77 per cent said no, getting an undergraduate education teaches students critical thinking skills needed for law schools.
Toronto lawyers Avra Rosen and Susan Sack have joined forces to start a new firm called Rosen Sack LLP.
The two lawyers have been friends since they were put in the same section at Osgoode Hall Law School in the 1980s.
“We are two very strong women, advocates, trial lawyers — very similar in the way we approach things and how we have compassion for our clients and strive for excellence,” Rosen says.
Called to the bar in 1987, Rosen practised family law while Sack initially pursued commercial litigation.
Rosen has had her own family law firm, Law Offices of Avra Rosen, for the last 19 years. She says one of her only sticking points of creating the new firm was that everything in her office remains purple — which has become what she calls her “colour trademark.”
Sack, who recently left Basman Smith LLP, focuses the majority of her practice representing family lawyers in LawPRO proceedings, but she also does some family law and commercial litigation.
The firm, which launched Aug. 15 with six lawyers, is set to move into a new space at the corner of St. Clair Avenue and Yonge Street in Toronto. The two lawyers say their skillsets complement each other well because the new firm will offer a complete package for family law clients who may need the help of a lawyer with estate litigation experience.
SOUTH ASIAN BAR ASSOCIATION WELCOMES NEW DIRECTORS
Five new directors have been elected to the South Asian Bar Association of Toronto’s board of directors.
SABA Toronto elected Aarondeep Bains of Aird & Berlis LLP, Neil Gurmukh of Miller Thomson LLP, Devin Persaud of Borden Ladner Gervais LLP, as well as lawyers Aman Patel and Vibhu Sharma.
The directors will join the board after being elected at the association’s 10th annual general meeting in August.
TLA CALLS FOR HONSBERGER AWARD NOMINEES
The Toronto Lawyers Association is calling for nominations for the 2017 Honsberger Award.
The annual award recognizes a TLA member’s accomplishment or ongoing contribution, which exemplifies knowledge, advocacy and community — the association’s three pillars.
The award is named after John Honsberger, a TLA president from 1967 to 1968 and association historian who was the first recipient of the Law Society Medal and the TLA Award of Distinction.
For a nomination form or for more information, contact firstname.lastname@example.org. The deadline for nominations is Sept. 30 and the award will be presented at the TLA Awards of Distinction Reception on March 2, 2017.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times reported recently that Legal Aid Ontario is reconsidering its practices around transparency in light of the province’s recent Open Data Directive.
Readers were asked if they thought Legal Aid billings should be kept secret.
Around 45 per cent said yes, releasing the data would violate the privacy of lawyers and the information would lack context.
The remaining 55 per cent said no, transparency and accountability would be enhanced if it was released, showing how public funding is used.
The Advocates’ Society has announced this year’s Catzman award will go to Donald Bayne.
The Ottawa criminal lawyer is known for defending high-profile clients in complicated cases throughout the years at all levels of courts.
Last year, Bayne successfully defended Senator Mike Duffy against charges of fraud, bribery and breach of trust in his trial.
Bayne, who is a partner at Bayne Sellar Boxall LLP, has practised criminal law for 36 years and the Law Society of Upper Canada has given him the designation of a specialist in criminal litigation.
The Advocates’ Society created the Catzman award in 2008 along with the Catzman family and recognizes legal professionals who exemplify knowledge of the law, integrity, fairness, civility, as well as a number of other virtues.
It was named after Marvin Catzman, a deceased former justice of the Ontario Court of Appeal, and is presented annually by the Chief Justice of Ontario in the fall. Previous winners include Toronto lawyer Samuel Marr, Superior Court Justice Michal Fairburn and lawyer Connie Reeve.
Bayne is a fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers, a past director of the Criminal Lawyers Association and the director of the University of Ottawa Heart Institute Foundation.
He will receive the award at the Opening of the Courts Ceremony in Toronto on Sept. 13.
MARCH APPOINTED TO ONTARIO COURT OF JUSTICE
A veteran criminal lawyer has been appointed to serve as a judge at the Ontario Court of Justice in Pembroke, Ont.
Called to the bar in 1992, Michael March has practiced mainly in Renfrew County. He has often taken on pro bono work in his career, developing a reputation for sticking up for the vulnerable and those in need.
Recently, March volunteered with Project Welcome, an initiative that sponsored refugees.
TORONTO FIRM HAS A LAUGH WITH BREXIT AD
A Toronto law firm has had a laugh at the expense of its counterparts across the pond.
Lax O’Sullivan Lisus Gottlieb LLP has circulated a postcard poking fun at the United Kingdom’s recent vote to leave the European Union. The card is in the style of a news story from the Guardian newspaper with the headline “LAXIT!” and informs readers that the law firm has decided to pull out of the U.K. (The firm does not have any offices in Great Britain.)
“The partners of Lax O’Sullivan Lisus Gottlieb, the self-proclaimed legendary Canadian firm of barristers and solicitors, have voted unanimously to close all their UK offices,” the tongue-in-cheek advertisement reads.
“This was a decision short in the making,” the firm’s managing partner, Matt Gottlieb, was quoted as saying on the postcard.
“Besides, I was personally exhausted from all the commuting and just want my wife back.”
The card also includes a made-up quote from the British Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson saying the firm will not be missed.
“I always found LOLG a really difficult acronym to pronounce,” it quotes him as saying.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times reported recently that the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that sent text messages can be used as evidence against the sender when seized from a recipient’s phone.
Readers were asked if they thought sent text messages should be considered private.
Almost 38 per cent said yes, sent text messages should be excluded as evidence, as they are a private communication between two people.
The remaining 62 per cent said no, they should not be considered private, as “senders are alive to the fact that their communications may no longer be private once sent of made.”
An Osgoode Hall law professor is set to launch a free investors clinic, thanks to a grant from the Law Foundation of Ontario.
Poonam Puri is starting the Investor Protection Clinic and Living Lab, which will help individual investors who suffer loss because of wrongdoing.
The clinic is a joint project with FAIR Canada.
“Canadian investors who believe they have been wronged or suffered a loss deserve a single point of contact to help them with their investment complaint,” says Puri.
“Our clinic, the first of its kind in Canada, will fill this gap. I’m really excited to be able to offer this unique hands-on learning opportunity to Osgoode Hall law students.”
Law students will staff the clinic, heralded as the first of its kind in the country.
The clinic will collect information and data on complaints, and will develop a plain-language grievance guide for investors who have fallen prey to fraud.
The Law Foundation provided Puri with a $98,959 grant to launch the clinic through its Access to Justice Fund.
The foundation announced a total of $700,000 for eight different initiatives that all look to help vulnerable investors.
Other winners who received grant money from the Law Foundation included the Canadian Centre for Elder Law, a division of the British Columbia Law Institute, the Canadian Foundation for Advancement of Investor Rights and the Fondation du Barreau du Québec.
OBA WINS INTERNATIONAL AWARD
The Association for Continuing Legal Education has given an award to the Ontario Bar Association for its use of technology in its continuing professional development.
The OBA received the honour for its OBA Institute 2016, which brought together 2,000 lawyers from across the province in February.
The OBA said technology played a big role in the gathering, connecting venues in Ottawa and Toronto through a number of methods, including two-way hubs, which allowed lawyers to participate in events in the other city.
DALTON JOINS DLA PIPER (CANADA) LLP
DLA Piper (Canada) LLP welcomed corporate lawyer Lauren Dalton as the newest addition to its Toronto office. Dalton will join the firm as an associate. Called to the bar in both Ontario and New York State, Dalton has experience in cross-border issues.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times reported recently that Paul Schabas, the new treasurer of the Law Society of Upper Canada, will be taking a “hard look” at the Law Practice Program, after concerns were raised that the program creates two tiers in the licensing system. Readers were asked if the review is needed.
Almost 87 per cent of respondents said yes, a review of the LPP is needed and there are outstanding concerns that require scrutiny.
Roughly 13 per cent of respondents said no, a review is unnecessary and the program has been introduced already. Any review would simply be window dressing.
It seems Canadian lawyers are spending fewer hours on pro bono work than they were last year.
According to the Canadian firms that sent their data to the 2016 TrustLaw Index of Pro Bono, their lawyers spent an average of 13 hours on pro bono work over the last year, a decrease of 1.8 hours from the previous index.
The percentage of lawyers completing 10 hours or more of pro bono also dropped by more than 25 per cent, to 26.9 per cent from 36.3 in 2015.
The survey average was 39.2 pro bono hours per lawyer in the last year.
However, Nicholas Glicher, director, legal, and head of African Programmes at the Thomson Reuters Foundation based in Johannesburg, says only four Canadian firms — Blake Cassels & Graydon LLP, McCarthy Tetrault LLP, Shearman & Sterling LLP, and Skadden, Arps Slate Meagher and Flom LLP — responded to TrustLaw’s request for data, which makes it difficult to “judge the whole of the Canadian pro bono community.”
In 2014, Canadian Lawyer conducted a pro bono survey offering more of an in-depth look at the Canadian pro bono market.
Gordon Baird, partner at McCarthy’s and chair of its National Pro Bono Committee, says he was surprised by the drop compared to last year’s index and is hoping to increase the firm’s hours up significantly.
“Our goal — although whether it’s ultimately achievable I don’t know — is to try to get to 50 hours per lawyer per year,” Baird says.
JEAN-FRANCOIS VADEBONCOEUR JOINS GOWLING WLG
A leading banking and finance lawyer has joined the ranks of Gowling WLG (Canada) LLP.
The international law firm recently announced the addition of Jean-François Vadeboncoeur to its Montreal office.
“Jean-François has a dynamic practice that complements the strengths of our firm-wide corporate commercial team,” said Peter Lukasiewicz, CEO of Gowling WLG Canada.
“With his unique banking, finance, and real estate experience, he'll help advance the scope of our corporate commercial platform to better serve the needs of our clients in Quebec.”
Called to the Quebec bar in 2001, Vadeboncoeur’s areas of experience include corporate law, banking, real estate, and financial services.
TORONTO LAWYERS ASSOCIATION TO HOST CALL TO THE BAR CELEBRATION
Called the bar in 2016? Have a drink on the Toronto Lawyers Association this fall.
The TLA is set to hold its Call to the Bar celebration on Sept. 14 for all lawyers who were called to the bar this year.
Wine and appetizers will be served at the event, which will take place at the Courthouse Library at 361 University Ave.
Registration for the event is free for members and those called to the bar in 2016 can sign up for a free membership on the TLA’s web site.
For more information, e-mail email@example.com or call 416-327-5700.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times reported recently that Legal Aid Ontario lawyers have filed a pay equity complaint on the basis that legal aid lawyers are predominantly female.
Readers were asked if they thought the complaint has merit.
Around 42 per cent said yes, Legal Aid Ontario lawyers are not paid sufficiently for their work, and any steps that can be taken to correct the pay gap are strategically valuable.
The remaining 58 per cent said no, this approach to addressing displeasure with wages does not make sense and a similar complaint already failed.
Adam Dodek wants to debunk the myth that the Canadian Constitution is boring.
The University of Ottawa law professor is releasing an expanded version of his book, The Canadian Constitution, which provides a primer on the cornerstone of Canada’s legal framework.
“It’s going to make the Constitution accessible and understandable to lawyers, experts and ordinary Canadians for the very first time,” Dodek says.
He says he felt the need to update the original book, which was released in 2013, in order to reflect legal changes and to expand on its explanations of the Constitution.
In addition to including the complete text of the Constitution Acts of 1867 and 1982 with an index, the expanded book also looks at each section and explains what it means, Dodek says.
“If you read our Constitution, you would think that the prime minister is a marginal figure and is essentially an event planner,” he says.
“So much of the way our Constitution works is sort of hidden beneath the text.”
The book also uses stories that highlight Constitutional rulings, such as that of the groundbreaking 1929 Persons Case, to help understand how the Constitution is applicable to Canadians’ lives.
“It makes it understandable and translates it into ways that everyone can understand,” Dodek says.
FINALISTS ANNOUNCED IN CHALLENGE
Six Ontario legal startups are through to the second stage of the Legal Innovation Zone’s Access To Justice Challenge.
Ryerson University’s legal incubator announced the winners from a pool of 10 nominees that pitched their solutions to enhance access to justice.
The startups that will get the chance to compete for $50,000 in seed money, including a $25,000 first-place prize, will be Codify Legal Publishing, JusticeTrans, Law Scout Inc., Legally Inc., Lex Cortex Ltd and ParDONE. The final winner will be announced Nov. 25.
CRIME RATES UP IN CANADA
Police-reported crime increased for the first time in 12 years in 2015, according to new information released by Statistics Canada.
The federal agency uses the traditional crime rate and the Crime Severity Index to measure police-reported crime. The CSI, which measures the volume and severity of crime, saw an uptick of five per cent in 2015 from the previous year, but it was still at a level that was 31-per-cent lower than in 2005.
Statistics Canada says the increase in the CSI was because of more incidents of fraud, breaking and entering, robbery, and homicide. The traditional crime rate, which uses the volume of reported crime relative to an area’s population, rose three per cent in 2015 from 2014.
There were 22-per-cent more attempted murders reported and a 15-per-cent increase in homicide. The CSI for Ontario alone saw an increase of two per cent, which Statistics Canada says is due to an increase in reported fraud. Toronto has one of the lowest CSIs of 33 consensus metropolitan areas with a rate of just 45.7.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times reported recently that lawyers are criticizing the Provincial Offences Act, when it comes to the legal process following careless-driving incidents.
Readers were asked if they think the POA needs overhauling. One hundred per cent of respondents indicated yes, the POA lacks consistency and is confusing when it comes to sentencing. It definitely needs updating. There were no respondents that said no, the way the POA currently works is just fine.
In a dramatic reversal, the Supreme Court of Canada overturned what had been called a “game-changing” decision by the Federal Court of Appeal, and ruled that non-unionized employees of federally regulated business are entitled to similar protections against dismissal as those afforded to unionized workers.
The SCC ruled six to three in the case of Wilson v. Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. In February 2015, the Federal Court of Appeal had held that federally regulated employers may dismiss employees without cause.
The general consensus previously was that employees governed by the Canada Labour Code could only be terminated for just cause.
The decision affects half a million non-unionized employees working in banks, telecommunications, airlines, and other federal enterprises.
“It sets the law to what we thought it was prior to the Federal Court of Appeal decision,” says Stacey Ball, of Ball Professional Corp., who was counsel for the intervener Canadian Association for Non-Organized Employees.
“Basically, you can’t dismiss someone on a without cause basis. The adjudicator has a standard right to challenge your dismissal now — that’s been reconfirmed,” he added.
The decision was disappointing to Ronald Snyder, partner at Fogler Rubinoff LLP in Ottawa, who represented Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. in the case. He calls it “unsettling” with “very significant consequences.”
LAW SOCIETY LAUNCHES INDIGENOUS ADVISORY GROUP
The Law Society of Upper Canada has launched an Indigenous Advisory Group to help guide the legal community’s implementation of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission report’s calls to action.
The group, which will be made up of legal professionals and elders from aboriginal communities, will provide advice to the law society on unique issues faced by Ontario’s aboriginal peoples.
“The IAG looks forward to working with the law society to advance and encourage reconciliation of indigenous peoples and legal systems with the Canadian legal system – its constitution, laws, legal framework, and jurisprudence,” said the group’s interim chairwoman Kathleen Lickers.
NORTHERN SUPERIOR RESOURCES APPEAL LAUNCHED
A junior mining exploration company has appealed the dismissal of its $110-million claim against the provincial government for breach of duty to consult.
Sudbury-based Northern Superior Resources Inc. filed a notice of appeal at the Court of Appeal in June, after an Ontario Superior Court justice threw out its claim concerning a loss of access to mining in an area new Thunder Bay, Ont.
The company lost its access in 2012 because of disputes with the Sachigo Lake First Nation. In its claim, the company said the government had failed in its duty to consult the First Nation and that the disputes were the result of a breach of duty on the part of the province. The trial judge dismissed the claim, saying the company could not reasonably expect to be compensated by the province, as it was never directly involved in the company’s relationship with the community.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times reported recently that the Law Society of Upper Canada voiced concerns over a proposed policy at the Ontario Securities Commission that would make lawyers eligible for up to $5 million in whistleblower awards.
Readers were asked if they thought this policy is dangerous for lawyers.
Around 40 per cent of respondents said yes, this proposed policy is harmful and puts lawyers in breach of law society rules and it should be nixed.
But 60 per cent said no, awards like this help root out wrongdoing and provide incentives to people to report unethical practices.
Lawyer Linda Rothstein is set to become the first chairwoman of the Law Foundation of Ontario’s Board of Trustees.
Rothstein is a partner at Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein LLP, who does civil and administrative litigation and has expertise in public law.The board had never elected a woman as chairperson before.
“It’s a real honour to take on this role,” Rothstein said.
“I’m regularly moved and impressed by the projects we fund; from teaching youth about their human rights to training front-line workers to assist women who have experienced domestic violence. We have a real opportunity and responsibility at the foundation to fund work that is actually making a difference and addressing people’s legal needs.”
Rothstein is also a past president of the Advocates’ Society and formerly served as a bencher in the Law Society of Upper Canada from 2007 to 2015. She will replace Paul Schabas, who stepped away from the position of chairman after he was elected to be the next treasurer of the law society in June.
FIDLER RECEIVES AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
Lawyer Jonathan Fidler is set to receive an award from the Ontario Bar Association for excellence in alternative dispute resolution.
Called to the bar with honours in 1975, Fidler is a certified specialist in civil litigation, who works as a mediator and arbitrator with Malach Fidler Sugar & Luxenberg LLP.
In addition to personal injury, he has practised negligence and insurance litigation.
The OBA award recognizes excellence in the practice of alternative dispute resolution as well as writing, teaching, and mentoring in the field.
“Jonathan’s nominator gave him the highest praise,” said Kevin Johnson, the OBA alternative dispute resolution section chairman.
“He is an exceptional advocate of the ADR process, while serving to educate and promote the skills and techniques needed to advance ADR.”
Fidler will be given the award at a dinner Oct. 27.
INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL LAW SYMPOSIUM
The Centre for International Governance Innovation is set to hold a one-day symposium that will explore new ways to translate international environmental law into practice.
Participants will hear from lawyers and judges that deal with environmental compliance issues. The symposium, which is free but requires registration, will take place July 20 at the CIGI Campus in Waterloo, Ont. For more information or to register, e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org.
LAW TIMES POLL
Law Times reported recently that a Senate committee is investigating how to help prisoners with mental health issues, including the use of solitary confinement.
Readers were asked if they thought solitary confinement should be banned.
About 48 per cent said yes, solitary confinement should be banned and that it is a travesty that such an inhumane practice is still being used to “treat” mental health problems in a developed nation such as Canada.
The remaining 52 per cent said no, while solitary confinement may not always be appropriately used, it still has a valid use in certain situations in order to amend prisoners’ behaviour.