Trial judge conflated actus reus and mens rea of offence

Supreme court | Criminal Law | Jury | Charging jury

Accused parents were convicted of failing to provide necessaries of life to their young son, who died of meningitis. Majority of Court of Appeal dismissed parents’ appeals. Dissenting judge would have allowed parents’ appeals and ordered new trial. Dissenting judge found, among other things, that jury charge was confusing, misleading, and deficient in describing key element of offence, and that trial judge did not properly instruct jury on fault element or mens rea of offence. Parents appealed. Appeal allowed. Conviction was quashed and new trial was ordered.. Reasons of dissenting judge of Court of Appeal were essentially agreed with. In particular, it was agreed that trial judge conflated actus reus and mens rea of offence and did not sufficiently explain concept of marked departure in way that jury could understand and apply it.

R. v. Stephan (2018), 2018 CarswellAlta 995, 2018 CarswellAlta 996, 2018 SCC 21, 2018 CSC 21, Wagner C.J.C., Abella J., Moldaver J., Karakatsanis J., Gascon J., Côté J., and Rowe J. (S.C.C.); reversed (2017), 2017 CarswellAlta 2403, 2017 ABCA 380, Jack Watson J.A., J.D. Bruce McDonald J.A., and Brian O’Ferrall J.A. (Alta. C.A.).

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

From ignored to a nation-to-nation relationship: Jason Madden’s 20 years advocating for Metis rights

Ontario Superior Court of Justice welcomes new judges Colin Stevenson and Gilead Kay

Ontario Superior Court upholds award of costs exceeding the damages in a personal injury case

Ontario Superior Court resolves estate dispute between siblings by passing over a sister as trustee

Erika Chamberlain steps down as dean of Western Law

Ont. CA orders new trial in pedestrian collision case due to unfair bad character evidence

Most Read Articles

Erika Chamberlain steps down as dean of Western Law

Ont. CA orders new trial in pedestrian collision case due to unfair bad character evidence

Ontario Superior Court of Justice welcomes new judges Colin Stevenson and Gilead Kay

From ignored to a nation-to-nation relationship: Jason Madden’s 20 years advocating for Metis rights