Audit trails were admissible

Federal appeal | Evidence

Evidence

DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE

Audit trails were admissible

Plaintiff employee of defendant Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) believed that her co-workers had improperly accessed her personal tax information using CRA’s systems when she heard them making comments about personal bankruptcy, since she had previously declared bankruptcy. After internal investigation, employee requested further investigation and claimed she experienced workplace harassment to point where she resigned. Employee brought action for misfeasance in public office. Employee appealed judgment determining admissibility of affidavit evidence respecting audit trails on motions for summary judgment and summary trial. Appeal dismissed. Motions judge found that recordation of access to employee’s CRA files occurred independently of any investigation, and audit trails were gathered for review. Motions judge found audit trails were “business records” under s. 30(1) of Canada Evidence Act and were not “investigation records” for purposes of s. 30(10) of the act. Motions judge made no error of law in concluding that because audit trails were business records, they were admissible. Motions judge committed no reviewable error in accepting explanatory portions in affidavits as admissible evidence as she required explanation of meaning of audit trails. Motions judge erred in failing to strike certain portions dealing with employee’s relationship with her superior as they had no bearing on issues, but ruling was not material to decision on motions.
Collins v. R. (Dec. 10, 2015, F.C.A., Eleanor R. Dawson J.A., C. Michael Ryer J.A., and Wyman W. Webb J.A., File No. A-211-14, A-343-13, A-356-13) Decision at 240 A.C.W.S. (3d) 846 was affirmed.  261 A.C.W.S. (3d) 316.


Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Ont. Superior Court upholds ruling protecting union rep's conduct despite procedural lapses

Ont. Superior Court confirms courts' power to order third-party evidence disclosure in arbitration

Ontario Superior Court removes arbitrator due to delays and orders return to trial in family dispute

Legal spending cuts by Human Rights Legal Support Centre is hurting litigants, lawyers say

Christopher Chorney and Christa Reccord appointed to the Ontario Court of Justice

Ontario Superior Court allows amended Westboro bus crash claim to proceed as individual action

Most Read Articles

OCA allows sanction against trustee who made ‘extreme and derogatory’ remarks about LGBTQ+ community

Upcoming LSO panel will consider growing population that can't afford legal fees or get legal aid

Ontario Court of Appeal confirms no loss of competitive advantage in motor vehicle accident claim

Legal spending cuts by Human Rights Legal Support Centre is hurting litigants, lawyers say