Arbitrators can't erase previous offers

Philip Epstein sees nothing wrong if the same person who conducted the failed mediation conducts an arbitration on the same matter (see “Lawyer touts benefits, responds to critics of med-arb,” March 12).

He reasons that judges run voir dires all the time and that just as they block out evidence that has been excluded, arbitrators can do the same.

The analogy does not fly. Voir dires do not deal with past negotiations. Even the most bombed-out husk of a failed mediation renders two critical pieces of data to the mediator: the best offers of both the applicant and the respondent.

Indeed, depending on the mediator’s style, he or she may have had a great deal of influence in shaping those offers.

For an arbitrator to presume to ignore this data is to bestow on him or her powers that we don’t even permit a judge. There is a reason, after all, that the pretrial judge does not run the trial.

It simply astounds that there are lawyers who think it possible and professional to run an ostensibly neutral hearing in full knowledge of past offers.
John Tamming
John A. Tamming Professional Corp.
Owen Sound, Ont.

Free newsletter

Our newsletter is FREE and keeps you up to date on all the developments in the Ontario legal community. Please enter your email address below to subscribe.

Recent articles & video

Ont. Superior Court upholds ruling protecting union rep's conduct despite procedural lapses

Ont. Superior Court confirms courts' power to order third-party evidence disclosure in arbitration

Ontario Superior Court removes arbitrator due to delays and orders return to trial in family dispute

Legal spending cuts by Human Rights Legal Support Centre is hurting litigants, lawyers say

Christopher Chorney and Christa Reccord appointed to the Ontario Court of Justice

Ontario Superior Court allows amended Westboro bus crash claim to proceed as individual action

Most Read Articles

OCA allows sanction against trustee who made ‘extreme and derogatory’ remarks about LGBTQ+ community

Upcoming LSO panel will consider growing population that can't afford legal fees or get legal aid

Ontario Court of Appeal confirms no loss of competitive advantage in motor vehicle accident claim

Legal spending cuts by Human Rights Legal Support Centre is hurting litigants, lawyers say